“You cannot introduce democracy to a country by using tanks.”

This is probably the best argument for allowing Ahmadenijad to speak at Columbia today:

A rally where each speaker denounces Ahmadinejad’s reactionary policies and just a few call explicitly for military action will still be perceived, on campus and around the U.S., as pro-war. The right-wing media, from Fox News to the New York tabloids, has already jumped on the event, and will spin it to favor their cause. Conservative organizations with no affiliation to Columbia’s campus, such as the David Project, have already signed on to the rally on Facebook, and are likely to distribute hundreds of warmongering flyers and picket signs. The rally will seem to be a sea of pro-war demonstrators — and the more people who attend it and the more organizations that endorse it, the more powerful this disastrous message will be.

A U.S. attack on Iran, which is not an inevitability but is a real possibility, would have consequences just as terrible as the invasion of Iraq. Thousands would die in initial air strikes, and more in the resulting backlash and regional conflagration. The work of Iranian campaigners for free speech, women’s rights, and lesbian and gay liberation, and against racism and anti-semitism, would be set back immeasurably. As Iranian Nobel Laureate Shirin Ebadi has pointed out, “Human rights are not established by throwing cluster bombs on people. You cannot introduce democracy to a country by using tanks.”



  1. Josh, you titled your article:

    “You cannot introduce democracy to a country by using tanks.”

    In fact, you can, and it’s been done. Germany, Japan, Israel and the US, for starters.

    With respect to Germany and Japan, the US invested seven years of post-WWII effort to construct democratic capitalistic states upon the remains of two countries that were neither democratic nor capitalistic before we blasted them with superior military might.

    Israel, of course, has been fighting for its survival every day since its founding in 1948. The never-ending threat to Israel comes from those freedom-hating muslims who show zero willingness to co-exist peacefully with anyone, including each other.

  2. i would like no_slappz to show backup for his last statement re: freedom-hating muslims without using any rhetoric that has been supplied previously.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s